In December the surgeon general's office released a new report to
the nation, focusing on mental health. Those who have been involved
in preparation of the document hope that its impact will be of the
same order of magnitude as previous surgeon general's reports on smoking
or on violence - to change the behavior of the nation.
Though the report is a long scholarly document that is half footnotes,
there are really only two very simple messages: mental illnesses are
real, and treatment works.
There are a lot of forces that get in the way of us realizing just
how real mental illnesses are. We place a high cultural value on the
belief that hard work and right thinking pay off, in terms of material
and emotional success. The idea of an illness in the mind stirs our
most irrational fears about losing control. The mental health professions
have in some ways played into our grand denial, sometimes by promising
too much and sometimes by promoting pseudoscience. These all contribute
to the stigma that still overshadows mental illness.
Right now, our attitude about mental illness is like our attitude
about cancer in the '50s and '60s. Remember when you couldn't say
the "C" word in public? Remember when it was an automatic death sentence?
Now most of us know someone who's beaten cancer; we don't smoke and
we don't go in the sun without sunscreen; and the beauty salon in
my little town carries a full line of "dignity" wigs.
Our wish to deny the reality of mental illness hurts us in the same
way as denying the facts of cancer hurt us. According to the World
Bank, of the ten diseases that cause the most disability worldwide,
five are mental illnesses. In the U.S., depression is the second most
costly disease of all, just behind heart disease, worse than AIDS,
cancer, arthritis, MS.
The news in the Surgeon General's report is that we know enough about
mental illness now to be sure that these are diseases of the brain,
with characteristic changes in the neuroanatomy. And, we know that
treatment can reverse these changes. Medication and psychotherapy
can change the neural pathways that mediate mental illness; this is
now an accepted fact. Mental illness is not incurable.
All is not rosy, of course. Though treatment can be effective, finding
effective treatment and paying for it can still be very difficult.
The surgeon general's report doesn't ignore these basic facts. But
by making it clear that mental illness is real, and that it's treatable,
the surgeon general takes away the legitimacy of all discrimination,
whether it's in our health insurance plans or in our hearts.